engineeringscalinganalytics

Implementing ClickHouse for Problem Banks: Fast Aggregations and Student Reports

eequations

2026-02-08

9 min read

Learn how to design ClickHouse schemas, ingest millions of practice attempts, and build fast teacher dashboards for problem banks in 2026.

Hook: When your problem bank scales to millions of attempts, reports slow to a crawl — here's how to fix that with ClickHouse

Teachers and engineers at edtech companies frequently hit the same pain point: the analytics that power teacher dashboards and student reports become too slow or too costly as the practice volume grows. You need sub-second aggregations for dashboards, near-real-time cohort reports for interventions, and a traceable event store for audits — all while retaining the flexibility to run ad-hoc queries for debugging and research.

In 2026, ClickHouse has solidified its role in high-performance analytics after major market momentum and investment in late 2024–2025. This tutorial walks through a production-ready architecture for a problem bank backed by ClickHouse: schema design, ingestion patterns (including Kafka and HTTP), query patterns for teacher dashboards, and performance tuning to handle millions of practice attempts per day.

What you'll build and why it matters (quick overview)

A canonical, append-only event table (practice_attempts) optimized for analytics.
High-throughput ingestion using the Kafka engine and HTTP bulk inserts.
Pre-aggregations using materialized views / AggregatingMergeTree / projections for sub-second dashboards.
Query patterns for teacher dashboards: per-class performance, problem difficulty, retention, and time-to-master.
Operational tips: partitioning, ordering, TTLs, compression, and distributed tables for scale.

2026 trends you should know

ClickHouse adoption in analytics stacks accelerated through 2025 — more managed offerings and enterprise features make it a compelling OLAP choice for edtech.
Real-time streaming is now the norm for dashboards: Kafka + ClickHouse ingestion patterns are battle-tested and supported by newer tooling integrations.
Cost-efficient pre-aggregation with projections and AggregatingMergeTree is frequently used to reduce CPU on heavy dashboard queries.
Privacy controls and data lifecycle (FERPA/HIPAA considerations) are critical — ClickHouse TTLs and anonymization transforms are used more often in production stacks. See security takeaways for data integrity and audit considerations.

Schema design: the single source of truth (practice_attempts)

Design principle: store immutable event-level rows that capture every student interaction. Use lightweight, typed columns and lightweight low-cardinality encodings for repeated string fields. Keep analytics-friendly columns (explicit timestamps, denormalized teacher_id/class_id) to avoid expensive joins in dashboard queries.

Schema: event table (MergeTree)

CREATE TABLE analytics.practice_attempts_local (
    attempt_id UUID,
    student_id UInt64,
    class_id UInt64,
    teacher_id UInt64,
    problem_id UInt64,
    problem_version String,
    correct UInt8,
    score Float32,
    time_spent_ms UInt32,
    hints_used UInt8,
    attempt_index UInt8, -- attempt number for this problem
    steps Nested(
      step_id UInt32,
      action_type LowCardinality(String),
      time_ms UInt32
    ),
    metadata Map(String, String), -- flexible metadata
    attempted_at DateTime64(3), -- exact timestamp
    submitted_at DateTime64(3),

    -- denormalized helper columns
    subject LowCardinality(String),
    difficulty LowCardinality(String),

    -- system columns
    ingestion_ms UInt64 DEFAULT toUnixTimestamp64Milli(now())
  )
  ENGINE = ReplicatedMergeTree('/clickhouse/tables/{shard}/analytics.practice_attempts_local', '{replica}')
  PARTITION BY toYYYYMM(submitted_at)
  ORDER BY (class_id, problem_id, submitted_at, student_id)
  SETTINGS index_granularity = 8192;

Why this layout?

Partition by month (toYYYYMM) gives predictable retention & fast drops.
ORDER BY (class_id, problem_id, submitted_at) supports the dominant dashboard queries: per-class and per-problem time ranges. Adjust order-by based on your most common filters.
LowCardinality on strings reduces memory and speeds group-by on categorical columns.
Nested steps keep step-level data in-line while still being queryable.

Distributed table for global access

CREATE TABLE analytics.practice_attempts AS analytics.practice_attempts_local
  ENGINE = Distributed(cluster_name, analytics, practice_attempts_local, rand());

Use the Distributed table for queries from application servers and dashboards; ClickHouse will route queries to shards and aggregate results. For multi-tenant edtechs, consider a shard key based on student_id modulo total_shards. If you need edge-friendly deployments, consider compact edge appliances and review options in our compact edge appliance field review.

Ingestion patterns: scale and reliability

Two ingestion paths are common and complementary:

Streaming (Kafka) for real-time events — high-throughput, resilient; best for powering near-real-time dashboards.
Bulk HTTP / Parquet/CSV loads — for backfills, nightly batches, or large-volume exports from upstream systems.

Kafka ingestion example (recommended for live dashboards)

CREATE TABLE analytics.kafka_practice_attempts (
    -- same column definitions as practice_attempts_local
    ...
  ) ENGINE = Kafka
  SETTINGS
    kafka_broker_list = 'kafka1:9092,kafka2:9092',
    kafka_topic_list = 'practice_attempts',
    kafka_group_name = 'clickhouse-ingest',
    kafka_format = 'JSONEachRow',
    kafka_num_consumers = 8;

  CREATE MATERIALIZED VIEW analytics.mv_kafka_to_merge
  TO analytics.practice_attempts_local
  AS SELECT * FROM analytics.kafka_practice_attempts;

This pattern decouples producers from ClickHouse and allows scaling consumers. In 2026, many teams use cloud-managed Kafka or Kafka alternatives (Redpanda) for low-latency delivery. Monitor consumer lag and backpressure closely — Buffer engines and proper consumer scaling are common fixes.

Bulk load (HTTP/Parquet) for backfills

Use ClickHouse's HTTP endpoint or clickhouse-client for bulk inserts. Parquet is efficient for large batches and preserves schema metadata.

curl -sS 'https://clickhouse.example.com/?query=INSERT%20INTO%20analytics.practice_attempts%20FORMAT%20Parquet' \
  --data-binary @attempts.parquet

Pre-aggregations: materialized views, AggregatingMergeTree, and projections

Dashboards expect low-latency aggregations. Instead of scanning raw event rows repeatedly, pre-aggregate into smaller tables at the right grain:

per-class-per-day
per-problem-per-day
per-student-week

Materialized view -> AggregatingMergeTree

CREATE MATERIALIZED VIEW analytics.mv_attempts_class_day
  TO analytics.agg_class_day
  AS
  SELECT
    class_id,
    toDate(submitted_at) AS day,
    problem_id,
    countState() AS attempts_state,
    sumState(correct) AS correct_state,
    sumState(score) AS score_state
  FROM analytics.practice_attempts
  GROUP BY class_id, day, problem_id;

  CREATE TABLE analytics.agg_class_day (
    class_id UInt64,
    day Date,
    problem_id UInt64,
    attempts_state AggregateFunction(count, UInt64),
    correct_state AggregateFunction(sum, UInt64),
    score_state AggregateFunction(sum, Float64)
  ) ENGINE = AggregatingMergeTree() PARTITION BY toYYYYMM(day) ORDER BY (class_id, day, problem_id);

Query the pre-aggregate and finalize aggregates in SQL:

SELECT
    class_id,
    day,
    problem_id,
    countMerge(attempts_state) AS attempts,
    sumMerge(correct_state) AS total_correct,
    sumMerge(score_state) / countMerge(attempts_state) AS avg_score
  FROM analytics.agg_class_day
  WHERE day BETWEEN '2026-01-01' AND '2026-01-14' AND class_id = 123
  GROUP BY class_id, day, problem_id
  ORDER BY day;

Projections: newer option for ultra-fast aggregations

ClickHouse projections can store pre-aggregated query results inside the same table and are automatically used by the optimizer. Use projections for commonly-run dashboard queries to reduce complexity of maintaining separate aggregate tables.

Query patterns powering teacher dashboards

Below are proven query patterns and optimizations to deliver responsive dashboards.

1) Class summary — per-day trends

SELECT
    day,
    sumMerge(attempts_state) AS attempts,
    sumMerge(total_correct_state) AS correct
  FROM analytics.agg_class_day
  WHERE class_id = 123 AND day BETWEEN '2026-01-01' AND '2026-01-31'
  GROUP BY day
  ORDER BY day;

2) Problem difficulty heatmap

SELECT
    problem_id,
    round(100.0 * sumMerge(correct_state) / countMerge(attempts_state), 1) AS pct_correct,
    countMerge(attempts_state) AS attempts
  FROM analytics.agg_class_day
  WHERE class_id = 123 AND day BETWEEN '2026-01-01' AND '2026-02-01'
  GROUP BY problem_id
  ORDER BY pct_correct ASC
  LIMIT 50;

3) Time-to-master (cohort retention)

Compute how many attempts a student takes before they reach X consecutive correct answers. Use event tables with sessionization in ClickHouse or compute in your application and roll up to aggregated tables.

Performance tuning checklist (practical)

Right-ordering — align ORDER BY in MergeTree with your most common filters; include date for partition pruning.
Partitioning — monthly partitions reduce maintenance overhead and speed time-range queries.
Use LowCardinality on repetitive string columns to cut memory and speed group-by.
Materialized views / AggregatingMergeTree / projections for heavy dashboard metrics.
Sampling for exploration queries (SAMPLE clause) to reduce cost on ad-hoc queries.
Compression codecs — tune compressions per column: e.g., use ZSTD with level 3–7 for general-purpose; delta encoding for timestamps.
Limit joins — denormalize teacher/class metadata; keep dimension tables small and use dictionary encoders for lookups.
Backpressure — when ingesting via Kafka, monitor lag and scale clickhouse consumer threads; use Buffer engine if you need ephemeral durability. See our operational operations playbook for scaling consumer patterns.

Embedding solvers and storing solution traces

Many edtech systems embed solvers that produce step-by-step solutions. Store solver traces as structured fields (Nested arrays or JSON columns) and index the key dimensions (student_id, problem_id, version). This allows teachers to inspect exactly what a student submitted and where errors occurred.

-- Example: include solver_trace as a String (JSON) or Nested for structured queries
  ALTER TABLE analytics.practice_attempts_local
  ADD COLUMN solver_trace String;

Best practice: keep the raw solver_trace but also extract the critical signals (first_error_step, hints_used_count, final_score) into separate columns so dashboard queries don't need to parse JSON at runtime. For feature extraction patterns, see feature engineering templates that show how to surface important signals during ingestion.

Operational considerations: scaling, retention, and privacy

Scaling

Use sharded clusters with Distributed tables for cross-shard queries.
Autoscale ClickHouse nodes or use a managed ClickHouse service for operational ease. For guidance on designing for failure and multi-provider resilience, review building resilient architectures.

Retention & TTLs

Use TTL to automatically drop or move ephemeral data to cheaper storage. Example: keep event-level rows for 1 year, freeze older data to an archive table or S3-backed ClickHouse table.

ALTER TABLE analytics.practice_attempts_local
  MODIFY TTL submitted_at + INTERVAL 365 DAY TO VOLUME 'cold';

Privacy

For FERPA compliance, redact or pseudonymize student identifiers for datasets used by researchers. Implement anonymized aggregates for shared dashboards and ensure access control at the application layer. ClickHouse's RBAC and row-level security features have improved, but combine with application-level checks. For security and auditing patterns, see the data integrity and auditing takeaways.

Monitoring & cost control

Track query latency and scan sizes via system.query_log; surface heavy queries to engineers. Observability platforms and playbooks for 2026 are helpful — see observability in 2026.
Use query limits & resource groups to avoid runaway analytics jobs impacting dashboard SLAs.
Store frequent heavy aggregates in projections or AggregatingMergeTree to reduce repeated scans.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

Pitfall: ORDER BY optimized for writes rather than reads. Fix: choose ORDER BY based on read patterns, not ingestion simplicity.
Pitfall: Parsing JSON in hot queries. Fix: extract fields during ingestion into typed columns.
Pitfall: Too many small partitions. Fix: keep monthly or weekly partitions depending on volume.
Pitfall: Missing pre-aggregations. Fix: profile dashboards and add materialized views or projections for heavy queries. For practical caching strategies and high-traffic API behavior, the CacheOps Pro review is a useful reference.

Example end-to-end flow (summary)

Students submit attempts to your application API; events are published to Kafka (topic: practice_attempts).
ClickHouse Kafka engine consumes the topic and a materialized view writes into the event MergeTree (practice_attempts_local).
Materialized views or projections compute per-class/day and per-problem/day aggregates into AggregatingMergeTree tables.
Teacher dashboards query the aggregated tables (or projections) via the Distributed table for sub-second response.
Backups: monthly partitions are backed up to object storage or long-term archive tables; TTL rules move data between volumes as it ages. For a real-world migration and zero-downtime backup approach, see this case study.

Actionable takeaways

Start with an immutable event table and denormalize the fields your dashboards need most.
Use Kafka + ClickHouse materialized views for real-time ingestion and AggregatingMergeTree for low-cost pre-aggregation.
Tune ORDER BY and partition scheme to match your most common queries (class, problem, time range).
Extract important solver signals during ingestion and keep raw traces for audits.
Use TTL and volume policies to control storage costs and comply with privacy rules.

Pro tip (2026): pairs of projections and AggregatingMergeTree now provide the best mix of query speed and operational simplicity. Measure and iterate: add projections for the top 5 slowest dashboard endpoints first.

Final checklist before you go to production

Heat-map your dashboard queries — design projections for the top consumers.
Test Kafka consumer scaling and measure end-to-end ingestion latency. Operational guidance in the operations playbook can help you plan capacity.
Validate TTLs and cold storage policies on non-prod data.
Run cost projections: CPU, disk, and network for your expected peak volume. For developer and cost signals when designing infrastructure, see developer productivity and cost signals.
Document privacy and access policies tied to each dataset.

Call to action

If you're building or scaling an edtech problem bank, try a quick proof-of-concept: stand up a ClickHouse single-node cluster, load a week of practice_attempts via Kafka or bulk Parquet, and implement one projection for the highest-traffic teacher dashboard. Measure latency before and after — you’ll often see 10x–100x improvements on aggregated endpoints. If you want, we can provide a tailored schema review and dashboard pattern audit for your problem bank — reach out and we’ll help you map from your existing data model to a ClickHouse-ready analytics design.

equations

Contributor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.